The history, chemistry, and geobiology behind rna steven a. Feb 26, 2019 the rna world hypothesis is a concept put forth in the 1960s by carl woese, francis crick and leslie orgel. The era between, and the focus of yarus work, is called the rna world. Whether this view is correct or not, it is clear that a small ribonucleoprotein world exists today in every living cell. It is rna ribonucleic acid long believed to be a mere biologic copier and messenger, that offers us this glimpse into our ancient predecessors. Francis crick himself has become much less enthusiastic about the rna world than watson. Noller subsequently provided evidence that ribosomal rna is more important. The most popular theory emerging from the primordial soup paradigm is that of the rna world, a scenario where life begins with selfreplicating rna molecules. It proposes that earlier life forms may have used rna alone for the storage of genetic. Life from an rna world is about these vanished forebears, sketching them in the distant past just as their workings first began to resemble our own.
Conformational plasticity of rna for target recognition as. Rna world, a highly improbable scenario of the origin and early evolution of life on earth article pdf available in journal of evolutionary biochemistry and physiology 511. Enzymatic catalysis which was earlier thought to be the exclusive domain of proteins, but is now. Some consequences of the rna world hypothesis springerlink. Pdf rna world, a highly improbable scenario of the origin. The nature of modern rna suggests a prebiotic rna world monographcold spring harbor laboratory, no 24 by gesteland, raymond f. Fifty years old marc neveu,1,2,3, hyojoong kim,1,2 and steven a. The rna world hypothesis is a concept put forth in the 1960s by carl woese, francis crick and leslie orgel. In the following i discuss some of these difficulties, some of the alternative hypotheses that have been proposed, and some of the problems with these alternative models. The initial darwinian ancestor michael yarus what rna can do by itself. Nature had to find a different route, a better shortcut to the genetic code.
Such rna culture could at intervals be transferred to fresh medium so that its development could be followed over longer time periods fig. Rna can act as a ribozyme, a special type of enzyme. Problematic chemical postulates of the rna world scenario postulate 1. Cech, howard hughes medical institute, university of colorado.
Jul, 2012 the following objections to the rna world hypothesis have been raised. The new third edition of the rna world updates this perspective, describing the vast array of newly discovered roles for rna in the modern world. The rna world hypothesis proposes that early life developed by making use of rna molecules, rather than proteins, to catalyse the synthesis of important biological molecules1. The ribonucleoprotein world was then an historical intermediate, in which proteins enhanced the versatility and effectiveness of rna enzymes. The phrase rna world is used in biology when exploring the idea that rna molecules may have served as genetic molecules and enzymes before dna and proteins the first specific genetic role discovered for rna in cells was as mrna intermediates. So here, says author michael yarus, is an album for interested nonbiologists, an introduction to our. There was a prebiotic pool of betadribonucleotides. The rna world, 2nd ed the nature of modern rna suggests a prebiotic rna world. The nature of modern rna suggests a prebiotic rna world. If the rnaworld was the first biological world there is little that one canlearn from biochemistry about prebiotic chemistry, except that the formation and polymerization of nucleotides were once prebiotic processes. The problems associated with the rna world hypothesis are well known. Many newfound rnas will be riboswitches, but more exceptional large and. Rna possesses the two essential properties needed for life.
The first two editions of the rna world 1993, 1999 shed light on the prebiotic era dominated by this versatile molecule, and provided an overview of the state of rna research at the time. Rna world the most popular theory emerging from the primordial soup paradigm is that of the rna world, a scenario where life begins with selfreplicating rna molecules. First, dna which holds the genetic code is converted into rna through a process known as transcription. Rna is too complex a molecule to have arisen prebiotically.
To describe early rna creatures, here called ribocytes or rna cells, yarus deploys some basics of molecular biology. From a biosynthetic as well as, arguably, evolutionary perspective, dna is a modified rna, and so the chickenandegg dilemma of which. In 1973, he and another eminent researcher into the origin of life, leslie e. Recent papers published in biosystems and molecular biology and evolution delineated why the rna world hypothesis does not provide a sufficient foundation for the evolutionary events that followed. Orgel, published a paper advocating the theory called directed panspermia. A new scenario for the early rna world semantic scholar. Benner1,2 abstract this year marks the 50th anniversary of a proposal by alex rich that rna, as a single biopolymer acting in two capacities, might have supported both genetics and catalysis atthe origin of life. Edited by raymond f gesteland, thomas r cech and, john f atkins. There is also the issue of where rna came from in the first place. The prerna world is assumed to have the same essential characteristic of the rna worldphenotype and genotype both reside in the same polymer, so no protein or related catalysts are required to be synthesized. The rna world is a hypothetical stage in the evolutionary history of life on earth, in which selfreplicating rna molecules proliferated before the evolution of dna and proteins. But discoveries since the early 1980s have shown that rna can do much more.
Biologists used to view rna as a lowly messenger the molecule that carries information from dna to the proteinbuilding centers of the cell. The rna world, third edition, is no longer available. Rna cofactors are universal in terran metabolism, but their rna components offer no useful reactivity. Rna is an extremely complex molecule, with four different nitrogencontaining heterocycles hanging off a backbone of alternating phosphate and dribose groups joined by 3. The second rna world is that of todays biological systems, where rna plays active roles in catalyzing biochemical reactions, in translating mrna into proteins, in regulating gene expression, and in the constant battle between infectious agents trying to subvert host defense systems and host cells protecting themselves from infection. The evergrowing world of small nuclear ribonucleoproteins. The advances that have made such a pursuit possible are rarely discussed outside of biolabs. In this model, the earliest selfreplicating nucleic acids whether rna, dna or some analogous polymer. Biological components from the rna world are not entirely extinct, and bioinformatics will continue to reveal ancient and new noncoding rnas. The rna world is a widely accepted hypothesis that explains two aspects of the origin of life. It can encode information like dna, and it can catalyze biological reactions like proteins. Atkins, university of utah, university college cork, and trinity college dublin. The term rna world was first coined by gilbert 1986, who was mainly interested in how catalytic rna might have given rise to the exonintron structure of genes.
And researchers have never located a piece of rna that can replicate itself from scratch. This learning project allows wikiversity participants to explore the socalled rna world hypothesis. Primordial soup, fools gold, and spontaneous generation. We will refer to the period when the informational macromolecule had a backbone different from ribose phosphate and possibly different bases as the prerna world. Experiments are beginning to confirm that the catalytic abilities of rna are.
The term also refers to the hypothesis that posits the existence of this stage. Although this last rna world is only perhaps one millionth of one per cent as old as the primordial rna world, it is a vibrant community, and i feel privileged to be. The below mentioned article provides a study note on ribozyme and rna world hypothesis. Although the ribosome is made up of both rna and protein components, structural and biochemical analyses revealed that the mechanisms central for translation the process of assembling a. Such a molecule must function as an rnadependent rna polymerase, acting on itself or copies of itself to produce complementary rnas, and acting on the complementary rnas to produce additional copies of itself. In addition to carrying genetic information, rna can fold up into a complex structure that catalyzes a. Because it can perform the tasks of both dna and enzymes, rna is believed to have once been capable of supporting independent life forms. Instead, said charles carter, a structural biologist at the university of north carolina, chapel hill, who coauthored the papers, the model represents an expedient proposal. In this model, the earliest selfreplicating nucleic acids whether rna, dna or some analogous polymer were elaborated into allrna genomes and catalysts. The first is the primordial rna world, a hypothetical era when rna served as both information and function, both genotype and phenotype. Hypotheses, facts and experimental results 175 moreover, large snrnps small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particles responsible for intron excision from premrnas have been identi. These are proposed to be vestiges of an episode of life on earth when rna was the only encoded component of biological catalysis. Rna world an introduction the rna world hypothesis is an attempt to provide an adequate answer to problems facing originoflife researchers in relation to the original information storage medium on primitive earth.
These molecules are said to have catalyzed their own replication, and through selection pressures, evolved into a complex population that led to living organisms. Apologetics press the rna world hypothesis explained and. Whereas rna aptamers have been examined for their 3d structures by xray crystallography or nmr spectroscopy 14, only three high resolution structures of rna aptamers in complex with target proteins have been reported. In 1981, crick published life itself, a whole book about that theory. Perhaps life began with an rna or rnalike molecule capable of copying itself, transmitting its genetic information to the next generation. Benner, hyojoong kim, and zunyi yang the origins of the rna world michael p. As a solution to the origin of life, rna world model comes. According to this hypothesis primordial cells lacking protein synthesis use rna both as the repository of genetic information and as enzymes that catalyse metabolism. Dec 19, 2017 the rna of the rna world hypothesis, he added, is just chemistry because it has no means of controlling its chemistry. The weakest form of the rna world hypothesis suggests only this episode existed. Such a molecule must function as an rna dependent rna polymerase, acting on itself or copies of itself to produce complementary rnas, and acting on the complementary rnas to produce additional copies of itself.
The rna world hypothesis is widely accepted by evolutionists, because it provides an alleged solution to a longrecognized problem in evolutionary theory. Finally, the third rna worldthat of rna technology and medical applicationsis a baby compared to even the second rna world, because it arose only in the past halfcentury. But the concept of rna as a primordial molecule is older, hypothesized by crick 1968, orgel 1968, and woese 1967. Evolution of ribosomes and translation from an rna world h. To date, no plausible explanation has been advanced as to how primitive selfreplicating rna molecules could have made the transition into modern cellular systems which. Evolutionist criticisms of the rna world conjecture quotable quote by cairnssmith. The rna world hypothesis is supported by rna s ability to store, transmit, and duplicate genetic information, as dna does. As we shall see in this chapter, there are in fact variations on common themes of structure that arise from the unique physical, chemical, and topological properties of the polynucleotide chain. Each snrnp is composed of snrna and about a dozen snrnp proteins. The inability of rna molecules to perform many of the functions of protein enzymes raises a third and related concern with regards to the tenability of the rnaworld paradigm.
Cech additional perspectives on rnaworlds available at. Alexander rich first proposed the concept of the rna world in 1962, and walter gilbert coined the term in 1986. And by 1993 he says, it may turn out that we will eventually be able to see how. The notion of the rna world places emphasis on an rna molecule that catalyzes its own replication. The worst theory of the early evolution of life except for all the others article pdf available in biology direct 71. These include telomerase rna telorna, primary rna pri rna, messenger rna mrna, guide rna grna, small nucleolar rna snorna, small nuclear rna snrna, ribosomal rna rrna, transfer rna trna, transfer messenger rna tmrna, signal recognition particle. The rna world doesnt tell you anything about genetics, he said. Copyright 2009 by cold spring harbor laboratory press. Dr graham cairnssmith, physical chemist, is well known for a bizarre theory that the first living organisms were clay minerals of the origin of life. Biologist carl woese holds that the rna world theory. It is now generally accepted that our familiar biological worldwas preceded by an rna world in which ribosomecatalyzed, nucleicacid coded protein synthesis played no part. Pseudoknots result from base pairing between nucleotides within a loop and complementary nucleotides outside of the loop.
Jun 26, 2015 according to a recent article at new scientist, why rna world theory on origin of life may be wrong after all, the rna world model of the origin of life is under attack. Carl woese, francis crick and leslie orgel in the 1960s. The updated original chapters are supplemented with new chapters on rna protein complexes, snrnps and snornps, telomerase rna, rnai, micrornas, noncoding rna, and many other subjects. Perhaps the strongest evidence for the rna world hypothesis is the fact that the ribosome, a large molecular complex that assembles proteins, is a ribozyme. The rna world and the diversity of rna catalysts in order to establish a common ground for discussion, a generalized view of the rna world is shown in figure 1. The rna world cold spring harbor monograph series, 37 by raymond f. There is, in addition, a phosphate group attached to the 5position of the ribose. According to a recent article at new scientist, why rna world theory on origin of life may be wrong after all, the rna world model of the origin of life is under attack. Transfer rnas trnas are small molecules whose maximum length is about 100 nucleotides. Betadribonucleotides see figure 2 are compounds made up of a purine adenine or guanine or a pyrimidine uracil or cytosine linked to the 1position of ribose in the betaconfiguration. Pdf rna world, a highly improbable scenario of the.
277 1076 1191 32 1268 599 663 174 139 1169 300 1414 48 1611 981 489 595 539 1252 978 1589 1500 968 1447 1066 1549 346 1567 1194 790 575 842 1230 399 1090 1371 1601 960 1297 909 931 169 716 1424 447 96 1325